Small Batch Peanut Butter Cookies

Soft, chewy, and full of peanut butter flavor! These small batch peanut butter cookies make only 1 baker’s dozen and are done in under 15 minutes!

Why This Recipe Works

In my house it’s just myself and my husband, Joe. So the need to have dozens of cookies on hand at any given moment isn’t really necessary (our freezer is already stocked!) It’s not that I fear we will eat them for breakfast, lunch and dinner. It’s actually the opposite, I’ll have to throw them in the freezer because they’ll go BAD.

Now before you go thinking “Man, Colleen… you’ve got some serious self control!” know that self control is a FACADE! I talk about this in my blog post on food obsession and how the “cure” to a lack of self control is actually permission to EAT those foods! This is what’s called intuitive eating and what I teach inside of The SociEATy.

The being said, sometimes I don’t want to make a giant batch of cookies! So, my go-to recipe to make is this one for small batch peanut butter cookies!

Or, sometimes I’ll pair them with half a batch of my chewy candy cookies or copycat Panera kitchen sink cookies for a little variety if I do want more cookies on hand!

Ingredients Needed

• Peanut butter. I use regular “JIF style” creamy peanut butter most of the time. If you use all natural you may need to adjust the recipe a bit depending on how dry or runny your peanut butter is (every natural brand seems to be different). If it’s too dry and crumbly add a touch of water or milk .

How To Make This Recipe

First, preheat your oven to 375 degrees and line a baking sheet with a silicone baking mat (you can find some silicone baking mats on Amazon for a super affordable price. SO worth it!)

Next, in a medium sized bowl combine flour, cornstarch, salt, baking soda and baking powder. Mix well and set aside.

In a large bowl or stand combine peanut butter and sugars. Cream them together for ~1 minute.

Now, add your egg, egg yolk and vanilla to the peanut butter mixture. Beat again until combined.

Add your flour mixture to the peanut butter mixture and mix well. Your cookie dough should be uniform and easily roll into a ball. It should seem a little greasy- this is good!

Take 2-3 tbsp of the dough and form it into a ball. Repeat this process for the remaining dough and place ~2″ apart on a cookie sheet. You should have ~13 balls of dough (AKA a baker’s dozen!)

Now, take a fork and dip it into a small bowl of sugar then press it on top of the balls of dough twice to create an X shape. Dip the fork back into the bowl of sugar between presses. Repeat for the remaining cookies.

Then, before baking, I like to add a quick addition sprinkle of sugar over all of the cookies.

Bake the cookie for 9 minutes, remove from the oven and allow to cool fully.

Recipe FAQs

Expert Tips

To easily measure peanut butter for recipes WITHOUT it being a pain to remove from the measuring cup just spray your measuring cup with non-stick spray THEN fill it your peanut butter will slide right out. It’s magical!

Other Cookie Recipes You Might Like:

If you love this recipe, be sure to leave a star rating on the recipe card and leave a comment below!

Don’t forget to pin it on your Pinterest board for later, or tag me on IG @no.food.rules if you try the recipe and love it!

XOXO

-Colleen